In the course of the Population Health Blog's last primary care encounter, a measurement of its height and weight determined that it was overweight. On the way to the examination room, the nurse apologetically provided a patient education leaflet. The physician let the topic go unmentioned.
These health care professionals clearly were not "into" managing weight issues in their patient population.
After reading this paper, who can blame them? A review of fifteen randomized clinical trials involving over 4500 patients showed that while primary care-based "behavior change for weight loss" results in statistically significant weight loss, the average amount was a clinically insignificant 3 lbs.
While web sites such as this provide useful pointers on engaging patients on the topic of weight loss, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (PSPSTF) recommends that persons with obesity be referred to a care setting that specializes in intensive multi-component behavioral interventions.
The primary care PHB agrees: these frontline clinics can screen for obesity using height and weight, but that's where their responsibility arguably ends. Until there is research that shows otherwise, the primary care setting is no place for management of weight issues.
The PHB's care was state-of-the-art.
Showing posts with label Obesity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Obesity. Show all posts
Monday, 3 November 2014
Monday, 15 September 2014
Is One DIet Program Better Than Another for Weight Loss?
As a population-health skeptic, the outcomes-focused PHB was never convinced that one commercial diet plan was "better" than any other. Not only are excess calories very efficiently turned into corpulence by a very efficient human metabolism, it didn't make sense that that persons could eat their way to weight loss with more [insert one of the following: protein, fat, fiber, pre-packaged meals or vitamins]. Last but not least, if all these commercial weight loss outfits spent a tenth of their marketing budget on real science, the PHB may have had the evidence it needed to make a recommendation.
Well, a meta-analysis of "Named" (you'd recognize the brands) diet program outcomes has been published in JAMA and the results are decidedly unimpressive. The good news is that all of the household-name programs result in modest weight loss compared to no diet. The bad news is that the loss of two to six pounds for each program was no better or worse compared to the others.
The PHB's take? It's up to the consumer to weigh their personal preferences for one type of diet plan vs. another. In addition, out-of-pocket costs may also play a role in helping sustain the dieter's motivation in getting their money' worth.
Beyond those two considerations, however, it's just a matter of eating less calories, not more of the latest nutritional fad.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)